In the crowded Ghantaghar market in Jodhpur I saw a stall selling bangles. Behind and to the side was the girl whom you can see in the photo above: face veiled and looking on passively. I jumped to a conclusion about the social standing of women in the town which The Family disputed. “The stall is managed by a woman. The buyers are women.” she said, holding that women participate in the economy. I could not disagree. There were as many women in the market as men. “But all the women are on foot, whereas the men are on two-wheelers,” I argued.

Later in the evening we walked through the Tripolia market, named after the triple gates in the walled city. The narrow lanes buzzed with scooters, and The Family pointed out that I had spoken too early. “Look at all the women driving scooters,” she said. Not only were they driving, there were also instances of two women on the same scooter (see the photo above). This was some kind of real-life Bechdel Test. In defeat I pointed out to her the wonderful triple gate which you can see in the photo.

The still widespread use of veils in Rajasthan has attracted a lot of comment. An audio guide in Mehrangarh claimed that it was adopted from Islam. I found a contrary view in an article in the venerable newspaper from Chennai, The Hindu: “Historians said the veil system was prevalent much before the Mughal invasion. “There is evidence of construction of separate `zanana’ chambers for women in the Chittaurgarh fort in the 11th century,” said Varsha Joshi of the Institute of Rajasthan Studies.” Varsha is a woman’s name, of course.

So both of us are still puzzled about this. Do women in Rajasthan have as much agency as those in the rest of India? It has the worst gender pay gap among Indian states, with women earning 59% less than males. In spite of that, this is a very ill-defined question in a state with a woman chief minister. Also, the 27 women members of the state Legislature (two of whom are from Jodhpur) make up 13.5% of the total strength. This places Rajasthan in the top half of India’s states when ranked by the fraction of women members of the legislature.

Author: I. J. Khanewala

I travel on work. When that gets too tiring then I relax by travelling for holidays. The holidays are pretty hectic, so I need to unwind by getting back home. But that means work.

4 thoughts on “Agency”

  1. Interesting read.
    As for the state of women in Rajasthan (or anywhere for that matter), stats should get precedence over anecdotal evidence I think. 59% less when it comes to pay gap is a sizable amount, where as 13.5% representation is not! And if that puts Rajasthan in the top half of India’s states when ranked by the fraction of women members of the legislature, then that probably tells us more about India than Rajasthan don’t you think?


    1. Maybe. But does that not say anything at all about the state? Also, disregarding the fact that other states have significantly smaller gender gaps in income would be cherry picking, isn’t it?


      1. Well I did not have that other bit of information in your post : how gender pay gap in Rajasthan compares with other states. All I was trying to say was statistical evidence should be preferred to anecdotal evidence, but we also need to be careful with those percentages before jumping to conclusions. Whether the data point is close to the population average or an outlier should definitely be considered as you rightly pointed out. 🙂
        P.S. Pardon my rant. I recently finished reading the book : ‘Thinking Fast Thinking Slow’ and I think this is one of the side effects : trying to be the ‘bias’ police 🙂


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.